Summary

  • Bartenders at all-inclusive resorts often water down drinks to keep costs low and ensure guests behave appropriately.
  • Even if you're friendly with the bartender, they're unlikely to make your drink stronger upon request.
  • Asking bartenders to customize drinks or use top-shelf liquor may not be well-received, as they prioritize following management's directives to keep costs low.

Do resort bartenders actually water-down drinks? That's a very popular question that many of us ask ourselves while hanging out at resort bars in Mexico, Hawaii, and all over the world. There's no doubt that there are numerous things that bartenders at all-inclusive resorts keep on the down-low while doing their jobs. But it just seems a tad nefarious that skimping out on already expensive drinks might be one of them.

It shouldn't be THAT surprising that certain popular, and beloved, all-inclusive resorts around the world constantly disappoint. They do have to live up to high expectations, after all. But some traits, including how bartenders prepare your glasses of liquid happiness transcends popular resorts and applies to just about anywhere.

Of course, travelers not interested on drinks, can choose an all-inclusive that don't factor drinks into their price.

Without further ado, here are how bartenders at most all-inclusive resorts prepare your drinks.

UPDATE: 2023/07/16 14:52 EST BY LUANA FERREIRA

Staying in an All-Inclusive Resort often means guests can have access to endless drinks. Yes, bartenders have their secrets to prepare the drinks and this list has been expanded to include more of them.

13 Yes, The Drinks Really Are Watered Down

A guest in the pool
Image by Engin Akyurt from Pixabay 
A guest relaxing in the pool with a drink placed nearby

Some hotel bars around the world offer a few of the most outrageous, generous, and creative drinks imaginable. But the truth is, most don't. And this is especially true of all-inclusive who have to keep their costs down due to "unlimited drinks." Therefore, watering down drinks is no myth, according to bartenders on Oyster. Additionally, if drinks are less strong, bartenders can ensure that guests behave appropriately as well as get to enjoy the resort more without being too hazy-eyed.

12 Even If Your Bartender Likes You, They'll Rarely Make Your Drink Stronger

A well-stocked assorted drinks bar
Photo by Chan Walrus on Pexels
A well-stocked assorted drinks bar

There are a number of secrets that your bartender just won't tell you directly, regardless of whether or not you think you have a good relationship with them. According to a number of bartenders interviewed for The Best of Life, typical bartenders won't even make your drink stronger if you ask them to. Sure, they may appear as though they do, but this is a facade. Usually, they'll just dip the straw in booze so things appear to taste stronger. However, there are exceptions to this. So, if you find a bartender who actually supplies you with a stronger drink, treat them well.

11 Telling Them How To Mix A Drink Is A Sure-Fire Way To NOT Get What You Want

pouring liquor into a clear glass
Photo by Adam Jaime on Unsplash
Pouring a drink 

While this point is included in a list about surprising secrets that bartenders wished we knew, it's really anything but surprising. Being a schmuck to any professional is a sure-fire way of not getting what you want, but this is especially true of bartenders. They tend to take their jobs really seriously. And if you know anything about it, you'd understand what an art form mixology truly is. But bartenders are also following strict commands from their management who are desperately trying to keep alcohol costs low at their all-inclusive. So, be understanding. And if you want something fancier, you're better to go to a regular resort or hotel and pay for it.

10 Saying That They're "Out Of Mint" Means They Just Don't Want To Make You That Mojito

Mojito on a bar
Photo by Tatyana Vega on Unsplash
Mojito on a bar

Being a belligerent jerk will get you nowhere fast. According to Oyster, every all-inclusive takes the safety of their guests very seriously. This includes making sure the bar areas are fun for everyone and not just the intoxicated knuckledragger causing a scene. In order to do this, management instructs the bartenders to water down the drinks of anyone they deem "out of control." If they don't do that, they'll cut you off completely. So, maybe try to have some self-control if you want to enjoy all that liquid happiness.

9 They Won't Give You Top-Shelf Liquor Unless You Ask For It... So, Yea... You'll Get The Cheapest Stuff

Spirit Tasting
Via: Benjamin Rascoe on Unsplash
A wooden bar counter is lined with empty glasses and bottles of liquor, ready for a spirit tasting

If you want top-shelf liquor, you're going to have to ask for it. All-inclusive do everything they can to cut costs, especially in the bar areas. That's because alcohol can get mighty pricey. Therefore, all-inclusive bars almost always make their drinks with the cheapest booze they can find; otherwise known as "well" or "rail" alcohol. If you want something premium or top-shelf, you'll have to ask for it and hope to God that you'll get it without having to pay extra.

8 Pitchers Will Always Have Less Booze Than Individual Drinks

Cocktail Cowboy Serving Drinks at Bachelorette Party in Austin, Texas
Pexels
Cocktail Cowboy Serving Drinks at Bachelorette Party in Austin, Texas

Ordering a pitcher can be a fun way to save money as well as share an experience with friends and family. However, according to The Best Life, pitchers almost always mean less alcohol. With the exception of beer, pitchers of anything at all-inclusive contain fewer shots than if you were to order individual drinks. This is because bartenders can easily follow directives from their superiors and cut costs by filling the pitcher with the non-alcoholic ingredients. This is much harder to do when mixing an individual drink.

Related: Foods To Skip At All-Inclusive Resorts, And What To Eat Instead

7 You're Going To Get Judged If You Use Premium Booze In A Mixed Drink

Drinks being served at a Hawaiian luau
Photo by Lee Vue on Unsplash
Drinks being served at a Hawaiian luau

According to bartenders interviewed for Business Insider, you're going to get judged if you ask for a premium grade-alcohol for a mixed drink. Why? Well, because it's a total waste of money. Using Pyrat in a Long Island Iced Tea will taste the same as using the lowest grade of rum you can think of. The same goes for using Grey Goose or Belvedere in a Bloody Mary; it's going to taste the same as if you ordered Polar Ice. Unless you've chosen a drink that's only partially mixed, such as a dirty martini or a gin and tonic, picking anything above a "well" alcohol is a sign of being a juvenile customer.

Related: All-Inclusive Resort Staff Doesn’t Appreciate When Couples Act Like This

6 You Will Not Be Served In The Service Area

Woman with red lipstick holding a cocktail
Photo by Aleisha Kalina on Unsplash
Woman with red lipstick holding a cocktail 

When you go to the airport, you know not to board a plane while it's taking off on the runway. So, you should know not to order your drink in the service area of your all-inclusive's bar. According to bartenders speaking with Business Insider, this is because they're in preparation mode. They're creating someone else's drink or handing it off to a server and therefore are too busy to take an order. The obvious solution is to go to the clearly marked area where you can place your order.

Related: 12 Worst Vacationer Habits (As Revealed By The Staff At All-Inclusive Resorts)

5 Begging For Free Premium Drinks Will Get You Nowhere Fast

Food and drinks served
Photo by Jay Wennington on Unsplash
Food and drinks served in the resort restaurant

As everyone and their dog knows, all-inclusive resorts mean that the alcohol is flowing and guests don't need to worry about whipping out their credit card at the bar. However, there is a big exception to this. At most all-inclusives around the world, some premium alcohol is available for purchase and no bartender will give it to you for free. So, don't ask! They hate that because it puts them in an awkward position. Bartenders have been instructed to only give free premium drinks away under very special circumstances. And these circumstances never include when they're begged for it.

4 Expiration Dates Can Be Overlooked

Eggnog drink
Shutterstock
Eggnog drink

In an attempt to stretch their resources during slower times, bartenders sometimes resort to tampering with expiration dates. According to The U.S. Sun, they may scratch off best-by or expiration dates on product labels to avoid serving older ingredients.

Most clients don't feel the difference, but it can happen. So, if guests find themselves at a bar enjoying a cranberry vodka or a refreshing beer, it wouldn't be entirely unexpected to encounter an off-taste or stale flavor on their palate.

People drinking cocktails
People drinking cocktails placed on a white wooden table

Drinks such as Margaritas, Piña Colada and Mojito are popular everywhere, and bartenders must prepare them each night. During busy seasons, it's common for the resorts to receive more people, and managing all the orders can be tricky. However, most bartenders have their secrets.

According to a Redditor, some bartenders create large batches of popular cocktails to meet the repeated demands of the night, allowing for faster and more efficient drink preparation. This approach helps save time, particularly in a dry bar setup, by avoiding time-consuming and less popular recipes and prioritizing simplicity to ensure smoother operations for the bartending team.

2 They Spend A Lot Of Time Preparing

Array of drinks on the water in Ibiza
Photo by Briony Brown on Unsplash
Array of drinks on the water in Ibiza

Preparing eye-catching and excellent drinks demands more than shaking cocktails. There's a lot going on behind the scenes, including juicing, fruit cutting and syrup-making, and it takes a lot of time. Therefore, it isn't a surprise that some of them prepare large batches of popular cocktails.

For example, when a guest orders a caipirinha, it involves cutting and juicing a handful of lemons. It also crosses their mind that their garnish supplies might end sooner than planned when clients request extra slices of lime or other ingredients.

1 They Might Prepare Better Drinks For Guests Who Tip

Group of people drinking Sotol in Austin
Photo by Mikhail Nilov

All-Inclusive resorts can be an affordable option when traveling. Guests should tip bartenders even when staying in an all-inclusive resort. There isn't a rule, but most people agree $1 per drink is a reasonable tip. Being generous with tipping can also help clients get top-shelf liquors and cocktails quicker. Similar to what happens at bars, it's also a way to stand out during the busy season and ensure you won't have to wait ages for your drink.

By the way, the tipping etiquette is also valid for the resort staff, even when it's all-inclusive. More generous guests can also hand gifts to the staff.

Next: Here’s What “All-Inclusive” Resorts In The Caribbean Might Bill (Surprised) Vacationers For